History of the Church

Calvary Baptist Church (then First Baptist Church) was founded on May 29, 1960. Below is a short history of the church.

Pastor Shawn McLain accepted the call of Pastor to Calvary Baptist Church.

Pastor Ordination
Pastor Shawn’s Ordination.
Pastor Shawn McLain
Pastor Shawn McLain at his desk.

After the resignation of Pastor Wilson, and a series of interim pastors, Marlin Bowes became the eighth pastor to serve at Calvary in June of 1997. After a ministry of 4 years, Pastor Bowes retired due to the health of his wife.

Pastor Marlin Bowes & wife
Pastor Marlin Bowes & his wife, Shirley

The next several years were characterized by “waiting on the Lord” as we sought a new pastor. During this time of transition, Calvary once again relied upon godly men to fill the pulpit as interim pastors.

After the resignation of Pastor Taylor, the church called Pastor David Wilson (1989-1993). It was during his ministry that Calvary Baptist join the General Association of Regular Baptist Churches (GARBC).

Through the years, there was an active youth ministry at Calvary Baptist Church, as well as ministries for children and seniors.

Youth Group with Advisors, Kevin & Ruth Horlacher.
1980’s-90’s Youth Group with Advisors, Kevin & Ruth Horlacher (far right).

During the ministry of Jim Taylor, the church saw its greatest growth, both in membership and in location.

Groundbreaking for new church building.
3/6/1982 - Pastor James R Taylor (center) and Board at the groundbreaking ceremony for the new church.

Between October of 1979 and March 6, 1983, both a parsonage and a new sanctuary were built, and the name of the church was changed to Calvary Baptist Church.

Church Parsonage
The church parsonage.

Pastor Baker and wife
Pastor Baker and his wife, _____?
Pastor Rex and Susan Stairs & Family
Pastor Rex and Susan Stairs & Family

The 1970’s and 1980’s saw the ministry of three men as pastors:

  1. Paul Baker (1969-1973)
  2. Rex Stairs (1973-1977)
  3. James Taylor (1977-1988)

In 1975, a Christian school (Calvary Baptist Academy) was established. The school was open until 1990, when insufficient funds forced its closure.

1983-84 CBA Kindergarten through 3rd grades
1983-84 Calvary Baptist Academy in Mifflinburg — grades K-3.

Church services in downtown store front.
Original church services were held in a downtown store front.

Calvary Baptist Church opened its doors on May 29, 1960 after a week of Evangelistic Meetings by C. William Sloat of Bellefonte, PA.

The church, known then as the First Baptist Church, began in a storefront in downtown Mifflinburg. They would continue at the same location for nine years. During that time, they were led by:

  1. Pastor(s) Kenneth Holtz (1960-1963)
  2. Robert Saltzgiver (1963-1966)
  3. Raymond Ackley (1966-1969)
Pastor Kevin Holtz & family
Pastor Kevin Houtz & family
Pastor Bob Saltzgiver & family
Pastor Bob Saltzgiver & family

It was during the ministry of Pastor Saltzgiver that the church purchased the land where the current church now sits. The name of the church was changed to First Independent Baptist Church.

Groundbreaking ceremony for new church.
NEW CHURCH BREAKS GROUND — Glenn Walter, a trustee of the First Independent Baptist Church in Buffalo Valley, breaks the ground for the congregation’s new church building. Pictured with him from left to right are Rev. Ray Ackley, pastor; Richard Hackenberg, and Donald Fogle, deacons; and William Gill, trustee.
1969 Church Building
1969 — The original church building was used for 14 years.